{"id":11525,"date":"2015-10-23T08:01:30","date_gmt":"2015-10-23T12:01:30","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/www.thenatureofcities.com\/?p=11525"},"modified":"2015-10-22T18:42:55","modified_gmt":"2015-10-22T22:42:55","slug":"an-antidote-for-the-unjust-city-planning-to-stay","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.thenatureofcities.com\/TNOC\/2015\/10\/23\/an-antidote-for-the-unjust-city-planning-to-stay\/","title":{"rendered":"An Antidote for the Unjust City: Planning to Stay"},"content":{"rendered":"\"13.Thompson-Fullilove\"In 1993 or thereabouts I entered a contest for women to depict what they did on a particular day. That day, I went to meetings early in the morning at Harlem Hospital. I took photos of the abandoned buildings on West 136th<\/sup>, where I parked my car, and photos of a huge plastic bag in one of the stunted trees. Later, on my way back to my office on W. 166th<\/sup> Street, I stopped to take a photo of man who was selling nuts on the street in front of a burned-out building.\u00a0 He smiled with tremendous pride\u2014when I took him a copy of the photo a few weeks later, he grinned and said he\u2019d send it to his mother so she would know he was trying to make something of himself. There were photos of the Stuyvesant High School students that I was mentoring for the Westinghouse Science Competition, and photos at home in Hoboken with my daughter Molly and some chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the oven. We were reading Ian Frazier\u2019s New<\/i> Yorker<\/i> article about plastic bags in trees. I didn\u2019t win the contest, but the exercise etched what I saw in memory.<\/p>\n
The extreme commodification of the land is leading to the destruction of human habitat. It is inimical to public health to sell off our neighborhoods and displace our communities.<\/blockquote><\/figure>Harlem had been devastated by decades of policies of disinvestment. Walking the streets was a painful experience because so many of the buildings had been burned out, and garbage blew in the courtyards and rats ran in and out. Working people were struggling to control the neighborhood, but drugs and violence were the order of the day. Most of my research was focused on describing the problems in front of me\u2014filling out our understanding of a terrible statistic reported in 1990 by Drs. Harold Freeman and Colin McCord: that a black man living in Harlem had a shorter life expectancy than a man in Bangalesh, at that time the poorest country on earth. Some of what I wanted to describe was the historical process that had stripped this neighborhood of its life-giving qualities. I was describing an unjust city.<\/p>\n

The more I learned, the more I realized that urban policies were playing a critical role in the neighborhood\u2019s collapse.\u00a0 From the stories people told us, I hypothesized that Harlem had collapsed from a series of blows, each one undermining and deforming the social structure, so that death and disorder replaced hope and social productivity. As my colleagues at the Cities Research Group and I deepened our explorations, we were able to name the terrible series of policies\u2014urban renewal, deindustrialization, planned shrinkage, mass incarceration, HOPE VI, the foreclosure crisis and gentrification\u2014that have and continue to undermine poor and minority communities.<\/p>\n

We\u2019ve grouped these policies together under the rubric \u201cserial forced displacement<\/a>.\u201d Displacement traumatizes people and destroys wealth of all kinds.\u00a0 Repeated displacement takes even more of the wealth and integrity of the weakened population. As St. Matthew put it, \u201ceven what he has shall be taken away.\u201d Through the lens of the agony of Harlem, I learned the somber fact that policies that destroy some communities and neighborhoods are catastrophic for the health of those in the direct path of the upheaval, but they also endanger the health of the whole of the US, and through us, the whole world.<\/p>\n

Let us take one example, New York City\u2019s implementation of the mid-1970s policy of \u201cplanned shrinkage.\u201d\u00a0 This policy was designed to manage \u201cshrinking population\u201d in the city by \u201cinternal resettlement\u201d of people from very poor neighborhoods and clearing the land for later use.\u00a0 Planned shrinkage was implemented by closing fire stations in those communities.\u00a0 This triggered a storm of fires: South Bronx neighborhoods lost as much as 80 percent of housing; Harlem lost 30 percent.<\/p>\n

We can trace many lines of disruption that rippled out from these epicenters of destruction. The upheaval caused massive social disorder and a \u201csynergism of plagues,\u201d as Rodrick Wallace called it.\u00a0 What no one knew when the policy was implemented was that a new virus\u2014which we now know as the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)\u2014was present in the very poor neighborhoods. HIV began to spread in the South Bronx and other NYC communities.\u00a0 The crack epidemic took hold, accompanied by massive violence, family disruption, and further spread of HIV infection. Mass incarceration was the federal response to the drug epidemic, unleashing an era of imprisonment that had horrific consequences for families and neighborhoods.\u00a0 By 2015, The New York Times<\/i> reported \u201c1.5 million missing black men,\u201d many in prison and others who had died prematurely. <\/i>Population fell, families fell apart, unemployment grew, church attendance declined, and trauma became a nearly universal experience.<\/p>\n

Having hypothesized the downward spiral of community collapse, my team and I realized we had to start searching for ways to rebuild. We worked first with families, then neighborhoods.\u00a0 But we learned that the fate of neighborhoods rested in the hands of cities. A great deal of our attention has been directed at learning what actions cities could take to counter serial forced displacement and to rebuild the much-needed social bonds.<\/p>\n

In 2007, I went to my hometown of Orange, NJ, for a celebration of the 50th<\/sup> anniversary of the fight against school desegregation.\u00a0 My parents, Ernest and Margaret Thompson, had led that fight. My father went on to organize for the political representation long denied to the African-American population, then 20 percent of the city. In 1958, he and others in Citizens for Representative Government created the \u201cNew Day Platform,\u201d which advocated for education, youth recreation, representative government and a more beautiful city hall, among other issues. Their work led to a more inclusive democracy and better schools for all children.<\/p>\n

While planning for the celebration of Orange\u2019s desegregation, I learned that a local community development corporation, HANDS, Inc. was continuing the work my father had pioneered.\u00a0 It was fighting to protect local housing infrastructure and to rebuild community in the face of serial forced displacement. I became so interested in the city of Orange that in 2008 I co-founded the free people\u2019s University of Orange along with Patrick Morrissy, Molly Rose Kaufman, Karen Wells and others.<\/p>\n

The University of Orange has participated actively in planning efforts in the city.\u00a0 The UofO lead the development of the Heart of Orange Plan, which became an official plan in 2010, endorsed by the state of New Jersey Department of Community Affairs, making the area eligible for tax credit monies.\u00a0 We have also invited architects and urbanists from Columbia University, Parsons The New School for Design, Montclair State University and Pratt Institute to work with us to understand the city. We have slowly developed a sense of the city\u2019s potentials and its vulnerabilities.<\/p>\n

Orange grew at the foot of the Watchung Mountains, a crossroads of east-west and north-south movement, in the heart of the Lenapehoking.\u00a0 Its excellent water and good transportation made it a natural site for industry. Hat making boomed after the Civil War, reaching a peak of 4.2 million hats a year in 1892.\u00a0 The new bourgeoisie equipped the city with a Stanford White library on a busy Main Street, a Frederick Law Olmsted Park and housing enclave, dozens of churches and synagogues, two settlement houses and a park-like cemetery.\u00a0 The African-Americans and Irish and Italian immigrants were tucked into ghettoes, their children sent to inferior public schools, while the well-to-do created superb schools and tracks for their own children to prosper.\u00a0 The city is so packed with the best and worst of American urban accoutrements that the University of Orange has developed a signature tour, called \u201cEverything You Want to Know About the American City You Can Learn in Orange, NJ.\u201d\u00a0 Orange has the advantage of being a small city, so visitors can see all of this in 2.2 square miles.<\/p>\n

But Orange now, like many other postindustrial cities, is worn-out.\u00a0 Sixty-five percent of the largely black population of 30,000 is poor and working poor. Many residents have immigrated from other countries and they speak a wide array of languages. Orange is a city in search of a future. In New Jersey, such places are being converted by \u201ctransit-oriented development,\u201d which means the unskilled workers are being replaced by those who commute to Newark\u2014or more likely New York\u2014to work in finance, insurance and real estate, the FIRE industries post-industrial cities have come to rely on. Orange lies just a bit west of Hoboken, Jersey City and Harrison, FIRE cities already remodeled as dense bedroom communities.<\/p>\n

For the people who live in Orange, transit-oriented development would be the next turn of the wheel of serial forced displacement. But it would also mean a loss of the complex vitality of people and institutions. Urban bedroom communities are monocultures, a variation on housing projects, albeit with better amenities.<\/p>\n

At the University of Orange, we\u2019ve posed the questions: Can\u2019t we take a more interesting path? Can\u2019t we develop new industries? Can\u2019t we help the workforce acquire skills so that they can compete for higher paying jobs and therefore hold on to their homes when the gentry arrive? Couldn\u2019t we combine of the idea of the civil rights movement\u2019s Freedom Schools and Edison\u2019s concept of the \u201cFactory of Invention\u201d to make a \u201cpost-industrial city reimaging lab\u201d?<\/p>\n

Some exciting opportunities have opened up that are helping everyone in Orange explore these possibilities. The John S. Watson Center at Thomas Edison State College has helped a consortium of cities, including Orange, develop an economic development strategy that will entitle the cities to apply for new federal funds.\u00a0 The Board of Education, with the support of nearby Montclair State University, has been able to develop community schools, including adult education.\u00a0 The University of Orange helps to manage the Adult School, which includes courses for workforce development. The Worldwide Orphans Foundation is bringing its first US-based toy library to Orange, and will be training local people to be toy librarians. At the U of O, we are partnering with a local arts organization and a university to understand how the insertion of a highway in 1970 might be mitigated. This project is supported by Arts Place. What we are learning as we go is that building the just city takes all of us.<\/p>\n

When I learned of a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation initiative focused on creating a culture of health in New Jersey, I convinced our local partners that we should apply for funding. The leaders of our \u201cHealthy Orange\u201d coalition will be expanding our connections to all sectors of business, industry and civic organizations and to all the ethnic and religious groups. Our leaders are insisting on engaging the current residents, <\/i>which <\/i>is critical in charting a path forward that is not another round of forced displacement. Instead of planning around this pattern of expulsion, we want to create a \u201cplan to stay.\u201d<\/p>\n

This concept, first advanced by Catherine Brown and William Morrish, is the antidote to serial forced displacement.\u00a0 Groups planning to stay are asked to answer two questions:<\/p>\n