DuneNYC

The Strategy of Sanderlings and the Tactics of Terrapins: What Was Hurricane Sandy Trying to Tell New York City?

Eric Sanderson, New York. 
January 2, 2013

Like an ancient prophet, armed with forebodings of doom and destruction, Hurricane Sandy bore down on New York City in the early hours of 30 October, 2012.  An extra-tropical cyclone, a thousand miles wide and armed with hurricane strength winds, Sandy was only eight days old.  A fitful infant terrible, Sandy had already visited havoc across Jamaica, Cuba, and the Bahamas; had been a tropical depression, a hurricane, a tropical storm, and a hurricane again; and might have spun without further harm into the north Atlantic Ocean, had not another, weaker storm from the Pacific coincidently crossed the continent on an intersecting trajectory.  Sandy abruptly turned west and made landfall over a spring tide, exaggerated by the fateful alignment of Earth, sun and moon.  The resulting winds and waves took the lives of 79 people in New York and New Jersey and caused an estimated $60 billion in damage, the second most expensive natural disaster in US history.  (Hurricane Katrina in 2005 is first.)  For the millions who lived, routines were disrupted by loss of power, then loss of fuel.  Business ground to a halt.  Lower Manhattan was dark for days.  Hospitals were evacuated, subways flooded, parks emptied, schools shuttered.  Only the salt marshes, a light green, grassy fringe along protected shores, seemed unmoved by the storm.


Hurricane Sandy over New York City. Credit: NASA http://www.nasa.gov/images/content/701204main_20121029-SANDY-GOES-FULL.jpg

A prophecy is a message, a communication from beyond the ordinary ken of human beings.  Prophets come to describe what is and to foretell things to come if we refuse to mend our ways.  What was the prophet Sandy trying to tell us about the nature of cities?  What was Sandy’s message about the nature of New York?

In the days immediately following the hurricane, it was hard to know.  The loss was too near, and the damage too extensive for anyone to address anything but the direct perils and mourn the losses just experienced.  But now some time has passed.  Some sixty days and nights later, and with the perspective of a new year just begun, we are given a new opportunity to re-assess what we have learned.

Sandy teaches us that it is not enough to be intelligent, we must also be wise.  Wisdom is more than intelligence.  Where intelligence aims to know facts about the world, wisdom is the use of that knowledge to achieve what is valuable; that is, to choose just and generous ends and to act with courage and deliberation to advance toward them.  An intelligent person knows what to do; a wise person does it.  In the twenty-first century, we have much knowledge, but often seem to lack the wisdom to apply what we know.  Prophets appear to give us the opportunity to change.


Sand bar and dunes in Jamaica Bay, with the Brooklyn and Manhattan skylines in the distance.  Along the outer edge, barrier beaches can have dunes 10 – 30 meters high.  Photo: David Maddox

And what do we know when it comes to cities and storms?  In New York and New Jersey, it is fairly clear what nature intends as a defense against bad weather from the sea: barrier beaches and dunes block the coasts and behind them salt marshes absorb the surge.


Once the force of the waves is spent, salt marshes slow and hold rising waters.  Photo: Eric Sanderson.

Barrier beaches are long, thin, low islands that form parallel to the shore along wave-dominated coasts; they are shields of sand.  Clearly evident on satellite imagery of the south side of Long Island and along the Jersey shore, barrier beaches continue in a long line south to the Carolinas and Georgia warding the eastern edge of North America.  In New York City, Coney Island in Brooklyn, Far Rockaway in Queens, the South Shore of Staten Island, and the FDR Drive at East Houston Street there are ancient barrier beaches, which old maps show were once surmounted with dunes, in some places thirty feet high, bulwarks held down by grass.


As this detail from an 1844 US Coast Survey chart shows, Coney Island is a barrier island that was once covered with dunes. Extensive salt marshes, shown with the parallel stippling, fill the area behind the beach protecting the old village of Gravesend.  Credit: Library of Congress.

Laying the modern building footprints in black over this historical map indicates the extent to which modern structures have changed the landscape, in some cases extending beyond historic land-water boundaries. Credit: Eric Sanderson.

Beaches and dunes form through the movement of sand, lifted out of the ocean, and deposited on-shore by wind and water.  They are unstable but not uncertain; guardians that never collect a day’s pay nor require maintenance except leaving them alone to do their job.  Hurricanes and Nor’easter storms infrequently but dramatically rearrange the details of the geography of these protectors by rearranging beaches, shifting dunes, and forcing open or closing shut tidal inlets, leading to the shallow basins behind.  March 4, 1931; September 21, 1938; September 14, 1944; March 6, 1962; October 30, 1991; December 11, 1992, all mark earlier prophetic visits in advance of Sandy.  In between times, the everyday inhabitants of the shore, sanderlings, dunlins, sandpipers, and killdeer birds, play along the tidal margin, coming and going with each wave, eyes and ears attuned to the atmosphere, ready to fly to safety when poor weather threatens.

Behind the beaches once stood, and still occasionally do stand, extensive salt marshes inhabiting shallow bays and inlet waters.  Jamaica Bay, Coney Island Creek, Great Kills on Staten Island – not to mention Flushing Meadows, Newtown Creek, and the southern Bronx River, elsewhere in New York – were all once great territories of salt marsh and seagrass, the second line of defense against great storms.  Salt marshes, or salt meadows as the old-timers knew them, are peculiar, grassy ecosystems that form in the inter-tidal zone; dry on the low tide, flooded on the high tide, salt marsh plants and animals make a virtue of existence on the edge.  Most can’t live there.  Plants can be drowned like we can, needing fresh air to breathe, and salt desiccates all, so the plants and animals that manage to survive there have special adaptations, not only to flooding, but flooding by salt water.  Spartina swards, for example, have special structures to carry oxygen from leaves above water into submerged roots, and mechanisms to extrude salt out of leaves, so that running a finger along the blade returns a harvest of briny crystals.  The diamondback terrapin, a local coastal denizen, actually cries salty tears to maintain its aqueous homeostasis.  Adapt to stay, turtles tell, climbing above flooded burrows to catch falling rainwater out of a storm.


This map shows the evacuation zones at the time of Hurricane Sandy. Data are from opendata.nyc.gov. Image credit: Eric Sanderson

Given some perspective on time and landscape then, it may come as no surprise that the first places to flood in hurricanes are the past and present salt marshes.  Overlays of the old, buried and forgotten, wetlands of the city and the new evacuation zones show a remarkable geographic concordance.  Wetland edges are often filled in coastal cities to make new waterfront property, but because fill is expensive and labor is dear, they are often raised only just enough to raise them above the tides.


Through the Wildlife Conservation Society’s Welikia Project, we are studying the pre-development extent of New York City ecosystems, including wetlands, as shown on this map.  The results are preliminary as the work is on-going.

Overlaying the historical wetlands and evacuation zones shows that low places are still low a century or more after the wetlands were filled in. Subway tunnels, basements, highways, and other structures in old salt marshes may expect to be flooded by new sea level rise.  Credit: Welikia Project,

And what if the tides rise yet further?


Sea level trends from the mid-1800s to today. Credit: NOAA

Knowing these facts, wisdom suggests we should follow the strategies of sanderlings and the tactics of terrapins as we plan to spend the billions of dollars that will flow back to the city from the larger nation.  Barrier beaches and salt marshes can protect us still, if we give them space, restore them to their former virtues, and enjoy the city behind them.  We should by all means visit and appreciate the beach as long as we are prepared to retreat to havens on higher ground when tempests approach.  And if we must leave some of our structures near the ocean’s swell, then for God’s sake (and our own), let us build only what is adapted to flooding and the motion of dunes and the surge of tides, so that when the next day dawns clear and bright after the storm, we too can return to celebrate the nature of a wise and resilient city on the ocean’s edge.

Eric W. Sanderson
New York City

Eric Sanderson

About the Writer:
Eric Sanderson

Eric Sanderson is a Senior Conservation Ecologist at the Wildlife Conservation Society, and the author of Mannahatta: A Natural History of New York City.

MORE ESSAYS IN...

SCIENCE &
TOOLS

Hyderabad
November 7, 2012 Maintaining Functioning Urban Ecosystems Can Significantly Improve Human Health and Well-Being Kathryn Campbell,  Victoria

With the global urban population expected to double to around 6.5 billion by 2050, the future outlook for biodiversity can be positive, particularly if biodiversity is seen as a part of the solution to some of our most urgent development...

4 Comment(s)
Join our Conversation

PEOPLE &
COMMUNITITES

RegularWasteDealers
May 17, 2015 The Waste Economy as a Transformative Gendered Practice for Sustainable Resource Management in Urban Africa Buyana Kareem,  Kampala

Frameworks for understanding the gendered nature of urban waste management have yet to emerge and analyses on the relationship between sustainable urban resource management and waste re-use and recycling at the neigbourhood-level are few. Those that do exist are more focused on city-level industry and infrastructure. This article illustrates how gender relations differentiate the ways in which women as compared...

2 Comment(s)
Join our Conversation

PLACE &
DESIGN

Water bodies of Jacaperaguá watershed
September 10, 2014 A Natural Offset for the Rio 2016 Olympic Park Pierre-André Martin,  Rio de Janeiro

Brazilian landscapes suffer rapid and repetitive transformations through intense and successive periods of exploitation—for example, the Brazilwood that gave the country its name, sugar cane, coffee, cattle, soy or urbanization and its infrastructural needs. Such degradation processes provoke losses of nature...

4 Comment(s)
Join our Conversation

ART &
AWARENESS

ParkReverie
June 12, 2012 Introducing “The Nature of Cities” David Maddox,  New York City

Sitting in the southern end of Central Park in New York City a few weeks ago, I found myself at what is called the “Literary Walk”. Statues of Robert Burns, Sir Walter Scott, Shakespeare and others decorate a cathedral of...

17 Comment(s)
Join our Conversation
David Maddox

David Maddox

Founder & Editor-in-Chief, The Nature of Cities Principal, Urban Oikos Partners LLC, New York, NY USA David Maddox is committed to the health of the urban ecosystem—urban resilience, the application of ecosystem services for human welfare and livelihoods, and the effective and efficient monitoring and evaluation of these issues. He has worked for The Nature Conservancy, for the Maryland State government, for the City of New York, in non-profits, and as a consultant. As Founder and Editor of TheNatureOfCities.com and Principal of Urban Oikos Partners LLC, his current work is in the development and dissemination of useful knowledge for design and management of social-ecological systems in urban landscapes. He holds a PhD in Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, with a statistics minor, from Cornell University and is a published playwright, musician and composer. He lives in New York City.

17 thoughts on “Introducing “The Nature of Cities”

  1. Pingback: jfd98ayhcim
  2. Pingback: Goozle Zone
  3. Pingback: URL
  4. What a great initiative. I am looking forward to all the conversations to come. Nature in the city is incredible, for those who haven’t visited, I encourage you to come walk through the Thain Family Forest in The New York Botanical Garden. It is a 50 acre old-growth forest, in the Bronx!

    Alex K., I enjoyed reading your paper. Did you by any chance look at any of the youth programs we have at The New York Botanical Garden? We host several programs over the summer and throughout the year that engage both Middle and High School students in research, education, ecological restoration work. If you are continuing this research, I’d love to talk sometime. In the meantime, check out this story in a local paper about Rocking the Boat building boats from Bronx white oaks that grew in the Forest. http://brie.hunter.cuny.edu/hpe/?p=5476

    1. Hi Jessica,

      Thanks a lot for your comment. What an amazing program you run! I visited your webpage, and watched some YouTubes, which include some of your work in the native forest and NYBG in general. I would like to encourage other readers of this blog to watch these videos as well. They convey very well the idea that cities can be viewed as ecologically valuable places:
      http://youtu.be/yedq7msP_X4
      http://youtu.be/XxTOSDzN2Mg

      These videos reminded me that the “Ecological Place Meaning” scale (http://www.esajournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1890/ES11-00318.1) could be adapted for a specific location to better measure the impact of specific urban environmental education or recreation programs. For example, in relation to NYBG, one could include in the ecological place meaning scale such items as “The Bronx is a place to harvest wood,” or “The Bronx is a place to learn about native forests.”

      I am very glad you shared the story about harvesting a tree in the New York Botanical Garden to build a boat. When I interviewed Adam Green at Rocking the Boat he also shared this story, and how this boat is now used to help students restore riparian habitats and oyster reefs in the Bronx River. I think it’s a very meaningful story.

      I would really like to learn more about the programs you run with middle/high school students or other audience. Recently I spent a couple of years in the Bronx while doing research on sense of place with community-based organizations along the Bronx River, but somehow I have not interviewed people in the NYBG. Once I visited NYBG with the group of students who were part of my research in Mosholu Preservation Corporation: http://urbanee.wordpress.com/2010/08/19/students-in-the-botanical-garden.

      What programs do you conduct with students in the native forest and NYBG in general (e.g., several week programs in summer, or one-day programs for school groups)? Do you have something going on now? If/when I’m in NYC next time, I would like to connect and learn more.

      Thank you.

      Alex Kudryavtsev
      PhD Candidate
      Natural Resources
      Cornell University
      http://AlexK.name

    1. Yes we do. You can follow us @tnatureofcities

      There is also a link on the Home page of the Blog.

  5. Great idea for a blog – I love this idea of the “built environment” as ecological space. Not as nature creeping its way into our cities, but as cities being a particular – and increasingly important – habitat for life. Urban ecology has a lot to contribute, I look forward to reading the posts.

  6. Delighted to discover your new urban nature blog. I’ve been blogging with a focus on urban wildlife from Manhattan’s Morningside Heights, which teems with raptors, herons, waterfowl, raccoons and many other other species. I look forward to reading more from you & your other writers. Great title, by the way.

  7. Welcome! I look forward to future enlightenment, controversy, and discussion. This is the moment, that’s for sure. I’m glad to be living through it. I’ve been documenting the life in my concrete backyard and the wider world — Brooklyn, NY, USA (plus a few places outta-town, on occasion) — for two years now, educating myself about I discover. The ancient urban/nature split is dead (although a lot of people haven’t gotten the e-mail yet).

    Matthew
    http://matthewwills.com/

  8. Congratulations on an excellent initiative and an insightful introductory piece to set the tone! I am certain that this critical space on the web will translate into a better understanding of these critical spaces, niches, in our cities.
    An appeal on writers and scientists from the Global South to add responses to what is a northern-dominated team (even the two “Southerners” are “Northerners”!)
    Best wishes to all at Urban Nature – Cape Town’s gift to the world!

    1. I absolutely agree about our need for more voices from south of the equator. South America and Asia are also generally unrepresented. (We do have a prodigal Aussie writing from Montreal.) Work and progress in urban nature is a global concern, and a core point of our collective is having diverse voices. We are a work in progress, naturally, but as our collective and site matures I am intent on adding new voices that fill these missing pieces.
      — David (attending the ICLEI Urban Nature conference in Belo Horizonte, Brazil)

  9. This new blog is a really great idea, and I look forward to reading future posts. To contribute to this conversation, I though I should share my new article on the development of ecological place meaning in the Bronx, New York City. It addresses nature in the city from the standpoint of environmental psychology and urban environmental education:
    http://www.esajournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1890/ES11-00318.1

    Thanks for your great blog!

    Alex Kudryavtsev
    PhD Candidate
    Natural Resources
    Cornell University
    http://AlexK.name

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *